Insurance carrier · Plan year 2024 · Form 5500 Schedule A

Medical Mutual

Medical Mutual appeared on 198 contracts at 191 employer health plans in plan year 2024 filings, with $346M in earned premium, ranking #23 of 1,452 carriers. Its medical contracts covered 33,391 people. Employers reported broker commissions and fees of $11M on those contracts, 3.0% of premium.

Premium

$346M

$346M medical

Employers

191

198 contracts

People covered

33,391

medical contracts, year end

Broker pay

3.0%

$11M · U.S. median 3.8%

Coverage lines on its contracts: health (185), prescription drug (137), vision (33), dental (19), PPO (11), stop-loss (6).

Where it writes the most

Medical premium by employer state.

$302M

$15M

$7.1M

$4.2M

$3.6M

$2.5M

$2.1M

$1.9M

$1.5M

$1.5M

Largest clients

Employer plans reporting the most premium with this carrier.

Employer	Premium	Participants
United Airlines, Inc. · Illinois	$14,892,587	126,338
Norwood Medical LLC · Ohio	$14,532,272	1,039
Macy's, Inc. · Ohio	$10,609,226	81,759
The NRP Investments LLC · Ohio	$7,819,157	692
Quadax, Inc. · Ohio	$7,322,650	771
Teamsters Local 348 Health & Welfare Fund · Ohio	$7,124,444	423
Hattie Larlham Center for Children With Disabilities · Ohio	$7,103,876	389
Overdrive Holdings, Inc. · Ohio	$7,013,229	544
Starbucks Corporation · Washington	$6,470,694	211,247
Ohio Education Association · Ohio	$5,760,663	355
Anderson Dubose, Inc · Ohio	$5,194,680	266
The Village Network · Ohio	$5,048,106	411
First Mutual Holding Co. · Ohio	$4,836,585	465
Norman Noble, Inc. · Ohio	$4,628,029	706
Axess Family Services, Inc. · Ohio	$4,422,018	305
Wiley Organics, Inc. · Ohio	$4,239,172	228
Step Forward · Ohio	$4,222,771	320
Minute Men, Inc. · Ohio	$4,098,145	189
Minute Men, Inc. · Ohio	$4,061,363	189
A. J. Rose Manufacturing Co. · Ohio	$3,883,226	371
Area Energy & Electric, Inc. · Ohio	$3,627,075	650
MGM Resorts International · Nevada	$3,583,024	31,639
Bricker Graydon, LLP · Ohio	$3,342,455	343
Child Development Council of Franklin County Inc · Ohio	$3,329,929	535
SG Chevrolet, LLC · Ohio	$3,211,513	156

Filed under 2 spellings, including Medical Mutual; Medical Mutual Services; this page adds them together.

Source: DOL Form 5500 Schedule A, plan year 2024; built October 24, 2026. One insurer's filed spellings (for example "Blue Cross Blue Shield", "BlueCross BlueShield" and "Blue Cross and Blue Shield" of the same state) are grouped on one page; different state plans stay separate.

How many employer health plans does Medical Mutual insure?

Medical Mutual was named on 198 insurance contracts at 191 employers with 100 or more participants in plan year 2024 filings, with $346,285,023 in earned premium and 33,391 people covered on medical contracts.

How much do brokers earn on Medical Mutual contracts?

Employers reported $10,552,599 in broker commissions and fees on Medical Mutual contracts, 3.0% of premium. The all-carrier median on fully insured medical plans is 3.8%.

Where is Medical Mutual strongest?

By medical premium, its largest states are Ohio, Illinois, Washington.